How the "Right Stuff" Went Wrong: Tom Wolfe & Stephen Hawking on the Apollo Moon Landing

The race to the moon was simply a Cold War battle; once Armstrong took that "one small step for a man," and we'd vanquished the Russians, there was little national stomach for making the massive investment necessary to fulfill Werner Von Braun's vision of a mission to Mars, says Tom Wolfe on the 40th anniversary of the Apollo 11 moon landing.  Wolfe, the icon of New Journalism and author of The Right Stuff.  writing in today's New York Times, argues that Neil Armstrong's step onto the moon was "One Giant Leap to Nowhere:"

"Well, let’s see now ... That was a small step for Neil Armstrong, a giant leap for mankind and a real knee in the groin for NASA.

"The American space program, the greatest, grandest, most Promethean — O.K. if I add 'godlike'? — quest in the history of the world, died in infancy at 10:56 p.m. New York time on July 20, 1969, the moment the foot of Apollo 11’s Commander Armstrong touched the surface of the Moon.

"It was no ordinary dead-and-be-done-with-it death. It was full-blown purgatory, purgatory being the holding pen for recently deceased but still restless souls awaiting judgment by a Higher Authority.

"Like many another youngster at that time, or maybe retro-youngster in my case, I was fascinated by the astronauts after Apollo 11. I even dared to dream of writing a book about them someday. If anyone had told me in July 1969 that the sound of Neil Armstrong’s small step plus mankind’s big one was the shuffle of pallbearers at graveside, I would have averted my eyes and shaken my head in pity. Poor guy’s bucket’s got a hole in it."

Wolfe's main point was The race to the moon was simply a Cold War battle, that once Armstrong took that "one small step for a man," and we'd vanquished the Russians, there was little national stomach for making the massive investment necessary to fulfill Werner Von Braun's vision of a mission to Mars. "How could such a thing happen? Wolfe asks rhetorically. "In hindsight, the answer is obvious. NASA had neglected to recruit a corps of philosophers" who could and would evangelize about the overarching value of such an investment.

Stephen Hawking, our century's Einstein, sees things differently than Wolfe. Hawking discussed his views on the profound significance of the mission on mankind in the introduction the to a just-published book Apollo Through the Eyes of the Astronauts, which he co-wrote with his daughter, Lucy, a journalist and author.

"In a way, the situation was like that in Europe before 1492," Hawking writes. "People might well have argued that it was a waste of money to send Christopher Columbus on a wild goose chase. Yet, the discovery of the New World made a profound difference to the old. Sending humans to the moon may yet prove to have had an even greater effect. It changed the future of the human race in ways that we don’t yet understand and may have determined whether we have any future at all. It hasn’t solved any of our immediate problems on planet Earth, but it has given us new perspectives on them and caused us to look both outward and inward."

While most of us might not have guessed we would not return to the moon after our last landing in 1972 until perhaps 2020, we should have guessed that human space exploration is inordinately costly and far more dangerous than we were led to believe by the initial successes of the Apollo missions.

Although fuel costs are another reason why it is so much cheaper to send unmanned missions into space, the chief obstacle against human travel to Mars is simply cosmic radiation. During the 18 months or so to do the round trip journey a lethal dose of radiation is likely to be received.

"Robotic missions are much cheaper and gather important scientific data," Hawking says, "but they don’t spread the human race into space, which should be our long-term strategy. If one is considering the future of humanity, we have to visit other worlds ourselves. Exploring other worlds won’t be cheap, but it will take only a tiny proportion of this world’s resources."

Hawking sees space exploration as critical to the human species long -term survival: "What’s next?" he asks: "Can we exist for a long time away from Earth? The International Space Station proves that it is possible for human beings to survive for many months away from planet Earth. Any long-term base for human beings, however, will probably need to be on a planet or moon, where subsurface enclosures can provide explorers with thermal insulation and protection from meteors and cosmic rays, and the raw materials that are necessary to create self-sustaining extraterrestrial communities can be found."

Hawking sees he moon becoming a base for travel to the rest of the solar system. "Mars is the obvious next target,: he adds. "It is half as far from Earth as Earth is from the sun and so receives half the warmth. Its magnetic field decayed four billion years ago, stripping the Red Planet of most of its atmosphere, making it impossible for liquid surface water to exist. However, the atmospheric pressure must have been higher in the past because we see what appear to be runoff channels and dry lakebeds. This suggests that Mars had a warm, wet period during which life might have appeared. There is no sign of life on Mars now, but if we found evidence that life had once existed there, we would know that the probability of life developing on a suitable planet was fairly high throughout the universe."

Ultimately our destiny will take us beyond our Solar System. "There are approximately a thousand stars within thirty light years of Earth,' Hawking states. "If 1 percent of each had Earth-size planets in a Goldilocks Zone, we would have ten candidate new worlds. We cannot reach them with current technology but we should make interstellar exploration a long-term aim. By long term, we mean over the next two hundred to five hundred years, and by exploration, we mean with humans."

Hawking sums up saying that the human race has "existed as a separate species for about two million years. Civilization began about ten thousand years ago, and the rate of scientific and technological development has been steadily increasing."  If we are to survive for another million years, "we will have to boldly go where no one has gone before."

This past year also saw the 40th anniversary of Stanley Kubrick's 2001: A Space Odyssey, a realistic and beautifully crafted version of Arthur C. Clarke’s vision of a future in which humans would travel throughout the solar system in search of both our origins and our future -a vision of a future shared by one of our species greatest minds.

The enduring legacy of the Apollo 11 landings is the ultimate reality show: the life or death future of the human species.

Posted by Casey Kazan

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/07/19/opinion/19wolfe.html?_r=1

NASA: Apollo Through the Eyes of the Astronauts

Related Galaxy posts:

Stephen Hawking: Why Isn't the Milky Way "Crawling With Self-Designing Mechanical or Biological Life?"

Stephen Hawking: "Humans Have Entered a New Stage of Evolution"
Stephen Hawking: "Asteroid Impacts Biggest Threat to Intelligent Life in the Galaxy"

Source: http://www.boston.com/news/science/articles/2009/07/15/07_15_09_appolo_11/?page=2

Comments

[Hp]

Do any of you know of a space chat is where one can post serious post on the subject and not have the whole blog deleted ie. 40 year blog all gone . Only post fluff here if you want to discus anything . Very pathetic .

[Narendra Nath]

The item has presented nothing substantial by way of techniques required for space travel or the specific purpose that requires missions to the moon. The problem Prof Hawking need to address concern as to how to generate a space vehicle that can travel faster than the velocity of light, knowing that this speed limit is only valid for homogeneous space. Space distortions ahead and behind the space vehicle may well usher speeds greater than c, thereby making space travel a truly meaningsul exercise. It is a challenge for technologists to work on!

[SCUBBA]

We won't do anything till we stop fighting over dirt, and look up.
then work together to get there.

[goatnut]

then we can fight over the new dirt we find up there

[ykmaheshwari]

I do not believe that technology to push the aircraft beyond the orbit of earth was available in 1969. Way back in 1980 timeframe first Intel 4004 type processor which could barely do maths. 555, 741 op amps were coming to market. If we know of huge IBM mainframes, punch cards and valve based computer.. the mission is fake. There is no way, telecom wireless would have had signals coming back from moon surface ..

Some info for people who are non-technical, let me ask :..watch the first step on the moon video and answer this --> Who was on the surface of moon, with camera to take photo of Neil Armstrong , while he is getting down from his spider shaped aircraft.
I have lot more to observe in this simple case..
If US cold war team, NASA and FBI would have its way.. then mysteriously enough I would be found dead in my home soon..

[pugay]

If the radius of Mars' orbit were half-again as big as Earth's, wouldn't it receive 4/9 as much heat rather than 1/2?

Also, what does the magnetic field have to do with having an atmosphere; I thought they didn't disperse because of the planet's gravity.

[replica rolex watches]

Hi,
That was really a great project and i am glad about that. It was really very important for many reasons because after that project we can know about lots of thing related to moon. I have read lots of articles on it and now i know the importance of that project. There are lots of hidden facts about the moon so i think now all those questions are going to be solved.
Anyways keep it up and keep continue with your valuable thoughts.

[tattoo removal cream]

Took me time to read all the comments, but I really enjoyed the article. It proved to be very helpful to me and I am sure to all the commenters here! It's always nice when you can not only be informed, but also entertained! I'm sure you had joy writing this article.

[Erasmo Seid]

lease, can you PM me and tell me few more things about this, I am really fan of your blog! I just subscribed to your feed. http://www.watcheslux.com

[replica handbags]

handbags,insurance is pretty high Chanel Handbags,cosmetic dentistry is not covered Gucci Handbags,the top media minds at

[massage equipment]

I really impressed by your post. Thank you for this great information, you write very well which i like very much.

[Tiffany Jewelry]

Took me time to read all the comments, but I really enjoyed the article. It proved to be very helpful to me and I am sure to all the commenters here! It's always nice when you can not only be informed, but also entertained! I'm sure you had joy writing this article.

[Medyum]

Took me time to read all the comments, but I really enjoyed the article. It proved to be very helpful to me and I am sure to all the commenters here! It's always nice when you can not only be informed, but also entertained! I'm sure you had joy writing this article.

[Watch Blog]

Several important watches were sold at the Christie’s 2009 important watch sale.

[Jerseys]

hi guys,a good news for all of you,we are retired nfl player who now owes a cheap jerseys

[fade watches]

I am a fanatic watch collection, especially the well-known watches, you also can do, click on my name!

[fadewatches]

I am a fanatic watch collection, especially the well-known watches, you also can do, just click on my name!!!!!!!!

[Circle_Pro]

As a branch factory of China Peteresa Group, Peteresa Fitness Equipment Co.,LTD was established in the year 2008, which is dedicated to design and manufacturer high quality home fitness equipments and machines. Our factory mainly supply:
Abdominal exercise equipments such as AB Rocket, AB circle, AB coaster, AB lounge, AB flyer, Total core, Balance power;

[omega watches]

xiaoxiao123 08 20

[cheap jerseys]

hey buddy,this is one of the best posts that I’ve ever seen; you may include some more ideas in the same theme. I’m still waiting for some interesting thoughts from your side in your next post.

[Metin2 Yang]

good luck. plz keep it away. lol

[coach hanbags]

I love the blog layout ! How was it made? It's so good! Amazing article, thanks, I will subscribe to you RSS now.

[Polka Dot Checks]

No updates?

[new era hat]

no updates

[iphone cellulari]

well done.